White Lily

White Lily

A review of White Lily by John Emil Vincent

Published on July 3, 2025

White Lily’s cover features a striking white flower – a flower that, on closer inspection, reveals itself a carnation. The opening poems clarify this mix-up as a reference to musician Laurie Anderson and director Michael Fassbender, but the process of misapprehension, disorientation, and discovery is also a fitting metaphor for the experience of reading the collection. Though dedicated to lyric poet Louise Glück, and sharing her propensity for minimalism, restraint, and mythological allusion, Vincent’s poems are a distinct species of their own.

White Lily
John Emil Vincent

McGill-Queen’s University Press
$19.95
paper
104pp
9780228023777

White Lily’s ironic, minimalistic stanzas sear like incisions across the page. Vincent does not dilute his poetic voice to please everyone, and readers seeking more emotional warmth or imagistic ornamentation may not find this collection to their taste. For those open to an exploration of darker emotions, however, White Lily is an intriguing interrogation of persona, unease, and the paradoxes of confession. Vincent complicates preconceived ideals of writerly honesty by presenting a speaker who repeatedly gestures to both the spoils and pitfalls of his deliberate self-performance: a speaker who bemoans the ease with which he can “fool” others by shrouding himself in an air of intellectualism, yet proclaims that he “won’t stop either after confessing this so there.”  

The collection is divided into three sections – “White Lily,” “Wrecked Utopia Tour of the Endless Mountain Region,” and “What Flowers Mean” –  the first of which I found especially compelling for the specificity of its self-critique and its tempering of painful emotions with interpersonal affection. Other standout moments in the book include poems where the speaker turns his acid tongue on homophobic strangers, as well as the collection’s final poem, “Tall Poppy Syndrome,” which concludes with a moving callback to the collection’s beginning. 

White Lily explores difficult mental states with a frankness that makes Vincent’s voice distinct. The poet’s strongest collection yet, these poems ask how to make peace with a self one can neither entirely disclose nor entirely escape. mRb

Madelaine Caritas Longman is the author of The Danger Model (McGill-Queen’s University Press, 2019), which won the Quebec Writers’ Federation Concordia University First Book Prize. Her poems have appeared in Room, PRISM international, Vallum, The Ex-Puritan, and elsewhere. In 2025, she received the Joseph S. Stauffer Prize in Literature.

Comments

2 Comments

  1. Gaynor Harding

    you have not fact checked the title. rookie mistake.

    Reply
    • Rebecca West

      Thanks for flagging!

      Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

More Reviews