Brave New Worlds

A review of My Name is Elizabeth!Ella May and the Wishing StoneNiniThe Adventures of Cosmo the Dodo BirdThe Adventures of Cosmo the Dodo BirdAll Good Children by Annika DunkleeCarl FaganFrancois ThisdalePatrice RacinePatrice RacineCatherine Austen

Published on December 1, 2011

Believe it or not, there are still some people out there who think that young adult (YA) literature is written by people who aren’t smart enough to write for adults. Those who demean the skills of teen fiction writers apparently haven’t bothered to actually read any of the many fine YA books that have been published in the last couple of years.

All Good Children
Catherine Austen


Whether you need a rebuttal for someone who stubbornly insists on stigmatizing the YA genre, or you’re looking for a great read for yourself or a teenager you know, Catherine Austen’s novel All Good Children is an excellent choice.

Max Connors, the narrator of All Good Children is a completely believable fifteen-year-old character. He’s funny, feisty, and incredibly annoying. He’s addicted to his electronic device or RIG (Realtime Integrated Gateway), sarcastic, highly critical of his hard-working single mom, and often downright nasty to his six-year-old sister Ally.

It’s easy to imagine Max and all the other teenagers who populate this novel torturing the substitute teacher at your local high school, or hepped up on a combination of super-size blue slushie and hormonal firestorm. But All Good Children doesn’t take place in our time. Max’s story is set in the near future, in a town called New Middletown. In New Middletown, the desire for security, the requirements of the pharmaceutical company that employs the town, and the enduring belief that financial rewards equal happiness have created a dystopian nightmare.

Max doesn’t get it at first. He thinks he’s just feeling a normal dose of adolescent aggravation against an adult world that, as far as he’s concerned, is too stupid to know better. In some ways he agrees with the way things are run in New Middletown. The constant surveillance means that, within the city limits, the world is relatively safe and sparkling clean. And as long as he continues to ace his schoolwork without even trying he’s pretty much guaranteed a good job later on.

But when he returns from a week away with his mother and sister, Max notices that things have changed. The rest of the novel tracks Max’s struggle to survive in a society where children are vaccinated to assure compliance. It seems the adults who have the authority to control him are in favour of the so-called New Education Support Treatment and it’s up to Max to figure out how to save himself and the people he cares about from becoming emotionless automatons. A fast-paced plot with lots of edge-of-your-seat twists and turns is sure to keep both adults and teenagers turning the pages.

Austen provides many nuanced details of life in the near future, from facts on transportation and garbage disposal to the devastating effects of global warming. Strong characterization as well as a thrilling and horrifyingly plausible plot all combine to make All Good Children a wonderful read. Great literature is never limited by its genre.

The Adventures of Cosmo the Dodo Bird
(Picture books)

Patrice Racine

Tundra Books

The four picture books and four chapter books that make up The Adventures of Cosmo the Dodo Bird are the first in the series of environmentally themed adventures featuring Cosmo the dodo bird and his intergalactic sidekick 3R-V. Written for young readers and originally published in French by Origo Publications, these stories are intended to inspire children to consider how human behaviour negatively affects the ecosystem.

The main character, Cosmo, is a dodo bird whose species was eradicated hundreds of years ago. A twist of fate and a wrong turn find Cosmo teamed up with 3R-V, an invention from the future whose mission it is to go back in time and transport into the future families of animals who are destined to become extinct. 3R-V and Cosmo set off on a quest to find another living dodo bird somewhere in the galaxy. Of course, they never actually find another dodo, but the ongoing search is the premise for the continuing series of stories.

The Adventures of Cosmo the Dodo Bird
(Short-chapter books)

Patrice Racine

Tundra Books

There is some overlap in terms of plot between the picture books and the short-chapter books. In both series, the first book charts the birth of 3R-V, the fateful meeting of Cosmo and the beginning of their quest. The picture books introduce us to Digger, a creature whose desire for treasure almost leads him to destroy his own planet; Fabrico, who learns that it’s bad to dump toxic sludge; and Zigor, who understands with Cosmo and 3R-V’s help that recycling is better than thoughtless consumption. The short-chapter books look at the dangers of climate control, the importance of respecting and nurturing the balance of nature, and how competition can destroy the ecosystem.

Racine’s motive for writing these books is entirely honourable. He obviously cares deeply for the planet and is committed to using his experience in brand imaging and visual communications to bring a message of sustainability and environmentalism to children. But ultimately his experience in the world of graphic design works against him in these books. The images of Cosmo and friends are likely the latest in digital imagery but they are often stiff and don’t invite the eye to linger on the illustrations. One has the impression that the stories are written versions of an animated cartoon or game rather than existing, as they do, first and foremost as books.

Francois Thisdale

Tundra Books

Nini is the story of a Chinese baby. The book follows her from before she is born, through her time in an orphanage, to her adoption by parents who live in a snow-covered house. As a big girl, she still remembers her birthmother’s voice, but also loves her adoptive parents.

Thisdale’s illustrations are beautiful, a highly textured combination of painting, drawing, and digital imagery. The pictures draw us in, creating atmosphere and tone, and ultimately establishing an unexpected connection between the Chinese and Canadian landscapes. Unfortunately, while it is obvious that Thisdale cares deeply about the subject of the book, the text doesn’t work as well as the illustrations. Pictures as lush and evocative as these deserve words to match.

Ella May and the Wishing Stone
Carl Fagan
Illustrated by Geneviève Côté

Tundra Books

In Ella May and the Wishing Stone, Ella May returns from the beach with a wishing stone that she lords over all her friends. When Manuel, Amir, and Maya get fed up with Ella May’s attitude and try to make their own wishing stones, the boastful protagonist does everything she can to make sure they know that her wishing stone is the only real one.

The charming drawings by Geneviève Côté depict a late summer’s day on the sidewalk. It’s easy to forgive Ella May when she finally comes to her senses and realizes that friends are much more important than possessions.

My Name is Elizabeth!
Annika Dunklee
Illustrated by Matthew Forsythe

Kids Can Press

In My Name Is Elizabeth, the drawings are simply delightful and Elizabeth, the outspoken protagonist, demands your attention from the first moment you see her determined expression peer out from under her ermine and oak-leaf crown.

Elizabeth is tired of being called anything but her proper name. Accompanied by her duck sidekick, she sets everybody right, and by the end of the story she shows us that even girls as determined as she is are capable of bending the rules when necessary. A good example of how a simple story and engaging illustrations can work together to create a wonderful book. mRb

B.A. Markus is a writer, performer, and performer living and working in Tiotia:ke/Montreal.



Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

More Reviews

Walking Trees

Walking Trees

Marie-Louise Gay brings us Walking Trees, a story that gives readers a taste of how sweet the effects of going ...

By Phoebe Yī Lìng

The Consulting Trap

The Consulting Trap

With a clear organizing structure, Hurl and Werner's book succeeds as a citizen’s guide to modern consulting.

By Noah Ciubotaru