A Rimbaud of our own

Reading Nelligan

A review of Reading Nelligan by Émile J. Talbot

Published on April 1, 2002

Reading Nelligan
Émile J. Talbot

McGill-Queen's University Press

Émile Nelligan is an uneasy classic. His poems, even the clumsiest, seem to have been written from a timeless vantage point. He belongs to the greater tradition of French letters in a way no other Québécois poet does. The official French website for poetry (www.Poésie française) includes Nelligan alongside Baudelaire, Racine, and La Fontaine and in fact provides 72 of his poems on-line (as opposed to 51 for Mallarmé and 32 for Villon). At the same time, as Émile Talbot shows in this lucid and sensitive study of the poet, Nelligan is perhaps the most Québécois of our poets, even if he belonged to a Quebec that has now vanished forever. In particular, his tortured brand of Catholicism, which nourished his acute sense of guilt – mostly, and unsurprisingly, over sexual temptations – as well as his virulent anti-Semitism and extreme misogyny, shaped his sensibility and instilled an obsessive melancholy in his spirit.

Reading Nelligan is a model of its kind and will be of interest to all admirers of the poet. Talbot brings to bear a detailed knowledge not only of the work but also of the milieu out of which Nelligan developed. He considers the pressures and influences, both familial and artistic, which went into the formation of this strange adolescent genius. As is all too well known, Nelligan wrote his famous work as a teenager, then spent four decades in an asylum; in this, too, seeming more of a damaged Rimbaud than any of his contemporaries. Talbot is eager to pierce through the legend of Nelligan and to this end he brings both learning and insight. Thus, though influenced by the French Parnassians, Nelligan bent their distinctive vocabularies and symbols to his own purposes. As Talbot notes, a poet like Heredia with his fascination for such words as “gold” (or) exhibits obvious affinities with Nelligan, whom he clearly influenced; and yet, while the French poet is concerned principally with outward, “objective” and massively sculpted presences, Nelligan is concerned less with the tangible than with inward states: his gold is interior, gleaming out from some hidden “Eden of gold.”

Whatever Nelligan’s limitations as a poet – his gauzy vagueness, his Parnassian veneer, his often repellent attitudes – he was a master of the French language. Certain of his lines, and certain whole poems, possess a rare magic. But a line such as the famous “Ma pensée est couleur de lumières lointaines” or the beautiful and moving sonnet (a form of which Nelligan was a real master) “Le vaisseau d’or,” are virtually untranslatable. To render the former as “My thought is the hue of distant lights” conveys nothing of the delicate interfusion of sound and sense in the original which, as Talbot justly remarks, is worthy of Verlaine. In addition, Nelligan is the great poet of adolescent melancholy; to read him is to relive those brief but searing years in which one plunged into what the poet called “the abyss of Dream.” Beneath the Parnassian paraphernalia and the Baudelairean poses, an intense sensibility pulses and burns and it is this, combined with his immense skill, which keeps Nelligan’s verse vividly alive.

All readers of French poetry as well as students of Québécois culture will be indebted to Talbot for his work. He writes a prose that is almost entirely free of jargon and he clearly loves his subject. My only complaint is that all quotations are left untranslated, so readers without French are effectively excluded from what is otherwise a superb and penetrating study. By coincidence, Reading Nelligan appears simultaneously with Paul Wyczynski’s Album Nelligan (Fides), a sumptuous compilation of photographs and documents which gives a definitive and living face to a poetic legend. mRb

Eric Ormsby is a poet whose work appears regularly in such journals as The New Yorker, Parnassus, and Descant. His fourth collection, Araby, appeared with Signal Editions (Véhicule Press) in 2001 and his book of essays, Facsimiles of Time: Essays on Poetry and Translation, appeared with The Porcupine's Quill at the end of 2001.



Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

More Reviews

Good Want

Good Want

In a vicious act of rebellion, Domenica Martinello demolishes the delusions of the capitalist pastoral.

By Martin Breul

The Social Safety Net

The Social Safety Net

In her latest book, Nora Loreto identifies the boogeyman of neoliberalism as the culprit of our present troubles.

By Jack McClelland